Compare Cities

Smithtown, NY vs Milwaukee, WI

Single · Comfortable · $3,000/mo

Smithtown, NYOverall winner

Smithtown, NY is approximately 48% less expensive than Milwaukee, WI based on cost of living including rent. This makes Smithtown, NY a more budget-friendly option for expats considering a move.

Smithtown, NY has a FIRE Score of 51/100, indicating its suitability for financial independence and early retirement. The city's safety index is 36.76, suggesting moderate safety levels.

Recommended profile: Smithtown, NY is best suited for digital nomads who prioritize experience over savings.

Side by side

Best in row

United States

Smithtown, NY

Nomad72

United States

Milwaukee, WI

FIRE80
Cost
Cost of living index
88.2
-
One person, excluding rent
Best in row. $1,367/mo
$1,550/mo
Family of four, excluding rent
Best in row. $4,939/mo
$5,600/mo
Total monthly, rent included
Best in row. $1,725/mo
$2,227/mo
Monthly savings
Best in row. $1,275/mo
$773/mo
Housing
1BR, city centre
Best in row. $1,150
$1,700
1BR, outside centre
Best in row. $975
$1,300
3BR, city centre
Best in row. $1,600
$3,000
3BR, outside centre
Best in row. $1,800
$2,300
Scores
FIRE score
Best in row. 61/100
50/100
Nomad score
27/100
Best in row. 55/100
Retiree score
55/100
Best in row. 76/100
Overall score
72/100
Best in row. 80/100
Safety & infrastructure
Safety index
36.8
Best in row. 76
Internet speed
Best in row. 200 Mbps
102 Mbps
Walkability score
-
-

Estimates from published local prices. N/A means no figure is published for that city.

About these cities

About Smithtown, NY

Smithtown is a solid, unglamorous Long Island pick where a one-bedroom outside the center runs $975/mo and a monthly public transport pass costs just $44, so a single adult can live on the budget tier of $1,085/mo without much pain. The trade-off is a small expat community and a FIRE score of 51/100, meaning this is a place to settle into a quiet suburban rhythm rather than chase a fast-track career or a buzzing social scene. With a safety index of 75/100, excellent healthcare, and a cost of living index of 88 against NYC's 100, it suits remote workers and retirees who want New York access without New York prices.

About United States

Best for families seeking high English proficiency and excellent air travel access, with no retiree or digital nomad visa available. Internet speed of 390.28 Mbps and a large expat community support remote work, but the cost of living index is 100 (global baseline). Key trade-off: no retirement or digital nomad visa, and a complex pathway to residency or citizenship limits long-term stays.

🛂

Planning a move to Milwaukee, WI? Make sure you have the right visa.

Answer 11 questions and get a personalized visa match in under 2 minutes.

Find my visa →

Compare any two visa routes.

Income thresholds, fees, processing time and residency paths, side by side. Search by country, including United States and United States.

Compare visas →

Smithtown, NY vs Milwaukee, WI -- Frequently Asked Questions

Click any question to expand the answer.